Open your own Bible and read the timeline yourself.
From the day Adam walked in Gan Eden until the day Moses died in the wilderness (2,658 years according to the ancient Jewish chronology Seder Olam Rabbah), not one complete Torah scroll existed on earth.
Abraham kept the entire Torah centuries before Sinai: Talmud Yoma 28b: “Abraham observed the entire Torah before it was given, as it says (Genesis 26:5): ‘because Abraham obeyed My voice and kept My charge, My commandments, My statutes, and My laws.’”
Jacob studied Torah for fourteen years in the academy of Shem and Ever without a single book: Talmud Megillah 16b–17a with Rashi: “Jacob stayed with Shem and Ever and learned Torah there for fourteen years.”
At Sinai the nation received and observed hundreds of mitzvot for almost forty years with nothing written except the Ten Commandments on the tablets: Exodus 24:12: “The Lord said to Moses, ‘Come up to Me on the mountain… and I will give you the stone tablets with the Torah and the commandment which I have written that you may teach them.’”
That was Plan A, and it was perfect. Just moments from fruition...
Plan A needed no Exile, no Messiah, no future Redemption. At the exact moment of the first tablets, Israel returned to the spiritual level of Adam before he ate from the Tree:
-
Talmud Shabbat 146a: “When the Jewish people stood at Sinai to receive the Torah, the impurity that had entered through the serpent was removed from them.”
-
Midrash Shemot Rabbah 41:4: “When Israel said ‘We will do and we will hear,’ they returned to the state of Adam before he sinned.”
-
Talmud Avodah Zarah 22b with Rashi: “At Sinai they were healed from the bite of the serpent.”
-
Sforno on Exodus 31:18: “At the giving of the first tablets they stood on the level of Adam prior to the sin, ready for eternal life and direct knowledge of God without intermediaries.”
Death would have been swallowed forever. The evil inclination would have been eradicated. Every curse from Gan Eden would have been cancelled that very day.
If we had waited forty days, Moses would have descended on 17 Tammuz with two miraculous sapphire tablets created and written by God Himself (Exodus 32:16). The letters were visible from both sides, the middle of the ע and the ס floated by miracle, and whoever looked at them immediately became wise (Pirkei Avot 5:6; Talmud Eruvin 54a; Midrash Tanchuma Ki Tisa 16).
The rest of the Torah would have been written on our hearts. Jeremiah 31:33–34 was scheduled for immediate, permanent delivery at Sinai:
“Behold, days are coming, says the Lord… I will put My Torah inside them and write it upon their hearts… No longer will a man teach his neighbor… for all will know Me, from the smallest to the greatest.”
“Plan A was never ‘Written Torah only. It was the Oral Torah alive in every heart and flowing from every mouth, exactly the tradition that ‘Written-only’ believers reject today while clutching the Plan B scroll, a scroll that only exists today because the Oral Torah was temporarily too heavy for us to carry.”
And the nations saw the same future:
-
Zechariah 8:23: “In those days ten men from the nations of every tongue will grasp the corner of a Jew’s garment, saying, ‘Let us go with you, for we have heard that God is with you.’”
-
Isaiah 2:3 and Micah 4:2: “For Torah shall go forth from Zion… and many peoples will say, ‘Come, let us go up to the mountain of the Lord… that He may teach us His ways.’”
If a printed book or Torah scroll were all that’s ever needed, why will the nations still beg a Jew to teach them in the messianic age? They have access! Because even then the Torah will live in Jewish hearts and flow through Jewish mouths.
Then came the Golden Calf.
We could not wait forty days for a living voice, so we built a dead substitute. Moses shattered the tablets (Exodus 32:19). The impurity of the serpent came rushing back (Shabbat 146a).
God, in infinite kindness, gave us “Plan B”: the Torah scroll we now kiss every Shabbat. It is perfect, holy, 100% divine. But every classical commentator says the same uncomfortable truth:
-
Rashi on Exodus 32:16 (quoting Tanchuma): “Had Israel not sinned with the Calf, they would have received only the Five Books and the book of Joshua; the rest of the Prophets and Writings became necessary only because of sin and exile.”
-
Ramban, Introduction to his Torah commentary: “Most of the commandments that appear later in the Torah were added only because of the sin of the Calf and the complaints in the wilderness.”
-
Sforno on Exodus 31:18: “The second tablets and the full written Torah came only because the first, higher level was lost.”
-
Ibn Ezra on Exodus 34:1: “The second tablets were inferior in every respect to the first.”
The pattern repeats throughout history
Plan B - Just as the Amidah (the standing prayer) replaced the Temple offerings only because the Temple was destroyed (Talmud Taanit 2a: “Since the day the Temple was destroyed, there is no day without curse, and prayer stands in place of offerings”)
Plan B - Just as the physical Temple itself replaced the universal knowledge of God that was supposed to fill the earth without a building (Rambam, Moreh Nevuchim 3:32: “The Temple became necessary only because mankind fell into idolatry”)
Plan B - The written Torah scroll replaced the heart-written Torah only because we could not wait forty days without building an idol.
The scroll is the bandage. We kiss it every week, and we should…yet we are also meant to remember what we’re kissing…Plan B.
Only one living tradition has kept the ladder intact and kept climbing for 3,300 years.
Every single morning, three times a day, every observant Jew…Ashkenazi, Sephardi, Temani, Chassidic, Yeshivish, Modern Orthodox…stands and declares in the present tense:
בָּרוּךְ אַתָּה ה’ … נוֹתֵן הַתּוֹרָה “Blessed are You, Hashem… who gives the Torah” - right now, today.
That present tense is a living witness: the same Torah given at Sinai is still being handed over, person to person, in an unbroken chain:
Mishnah Avot 1:1: “Moses received the Torah from Sinai and transmitted it to Joshua, Joshua to the Elders, the Elders to the Prophets, and the Prophets transmitted it to the Men of the Great Assembly…”
That chain has many beautiful branches today, each preserving the mesorah with love and sacrifice. Among them, the ancient Temani-Yemenite tradition is treasured for its remarkable continuity: two thousand years in near-total isolation preserved the exact biblical pronunciation, the Rambam-centered halachah, and many customs that look and sound strikingly close to what the nation experienced at Sinai. It is one living window…among many faithful windows…through which a seeker can still hear echoes of the voice that thundered from the mountain.
Every mitzvah, every line of Talmud, every question asked in a beit midrash today is one more rung on the ladder back to the level we lost on 17 Tammuz.
You want the real Sinai experience…where God speaks and we actually listen?
Classical Judaism is the only phone line that never hung up. Every morning the entire Jewish world picks up the receiver and says, “Hashem, You are still giving the Torah, right now.” And then we walk into a beit midrash where living men are still giving it.
Put the scroll down for two minutes without ceasing to love it. Find a genuine talmid chacham whose chain reaches Sinai…yes, they exist. Whether you sit with a Temani scholar in the Baladi mesorah, a Mir rosh yeshiva, a Sephardi rav in the old Jerusalem style, or any faithful Jewish teacher…the voice that spoke at the mountain is still speaking through living mouths.
Hear the same Torah that was never written for 2,658 years being given again today in the present tense.
If this stirs your soul toward that unbroken chain, take the next step with a halachic path that honors it fully. At ConversionJudaism.com we guide sincere seekers through an efficient Orthodox conversion rooted in the Talmud’s own instructions (Yevamot 47a-b) and Rambam’s standards (Hilchot Issurei Biah 13–14), overseen by our Temani-influenced rabbi and kosher Beit Din…one of the many valid paths that lead straight back to Sinai. Begin with our foundational Avodah Zara course, renounce idolatry, meet the beit din, accept the mitzvot, immerse in the mikveh, and build your bayit ne’eman b’Yisrael (faithful house in Israel) with the love commanded in Deuteronomy 10:19. Allow a living voice to lead you home.
Plan A is still waiting.
Start climbing.
The Torah is still being given.
